
Hotel Alameda Highline
Best for creative travelers who prioritize Chelsea nightlife, rooftop pool time and flexible on-site event venues.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Alameda Highline is a 4.5-star boutique in Chelsea with arts-forward design, rooftop pool access and multiple event venues; read this if you want a lively Chelsea base near the High Line. Four Seasons Hotel New York is a high-profile 5-star Midtown luxury tower with large suites, full-service meeting spaces and polished service; read this if you want traditional uptown luxury close to Central Park and Fifth Avenue.
Updated · about 3.6 km apart

Best for creative travelers who prioritize Chelsea nightlife, rooftop pool time and flexible on-site event venues.

Best for travelers seeking polished Midtown luxury, larger suites and extensive conference/meeting facilities.
When Hotel Alameda Highline wins: choose Alameda if you want a smaller, design-forward Chelsea hotel with a seasonal rooftop pool, on-site Mediterranean dining, a cellar listening bar and easy steps onto the High Line. It’s also the more venue-driven choice for rooftop parties and afterparties.
When Four Seasons Hotel New York wins: pick the Four Seasons if you want classic full-service luxury in Midtown—large, individually decorated guestrooms and suites, a recognized Four Seasons spa program, extensive meeting and ballroom space, and immediate access to Fifth Avenue and Central Park.
Bottom line: Alameda is the artsy, event-first boutique for stays centered on Chelsea nightlife and the High Line; Four Seasons is the safer bet for traditional luxury, larger suites and business or upscale leisure travel in Midtown.
| Category | Hotel Alameda Highline | Four Seasons Hotel New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, artsy, venue-forward | Polished, traditional Midtown luxury |
| Location | Chelsea, steps from the High Line and close to Hudson Yards | Midtown East, on E 57th Street near Fifth Avenue and Central Park |
| Size (rooms) | About 56–61 rooms (boutique scale) | 368 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Star rating / guest score | 4.5-star boutique (brand/marketing) | 5-star · user rating 9.4 |
| Pools | Seasonal rooftop swimming pool (typically 9am–7pm) | Indoor pool (Four Seasons spa complex) |
| Restaurants & bars | Lobby Bar & Garden, Creatures Rooftop, Music For A While (cellar listening bar) | The Garden Restaurant (on-site) + bar/lounge and 24-hour room service |
| Spa / wellness | Fitness center on site; no confirmed full-service spa | Full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Meetings & events | Three bookable event venues (Lobby Bar & Garden, Creatures Rooftop, Music For A While); full-buildout buyouts possible | Large conference center and meeting rooms with ~12,120 sq ft (1,126 m²) of event space, ballroom |
| Accessibility & family policy | All-ages property; minimum check-in age for main guest 21; not listed as wheelchair accessible in some sources | All-ages property; check-in min age 18; wheelchair accessible (may have limitations) |
| Nearby highlights | High Line, Hudson Yards, Chelsea Market, Chelsea Piers | Fifth Avenue, Central Park, Rockefeller Center, MoMA |
Hotel Alameda Highline sits at 518 W 27th Street, directly adjacent to the High Line and within easy walking distance of Hudson Yards and Chelsea Market.
Alameda is the better choice if you want direct High Line access and a Chelsea neighborhood feel.
Four Seasons Hotel New York is on E 57th Street near Fifth Avenue, a short walk to Central Park and core Midtown attractions.
Four Seasons is more convenient for Fifth Avenue, Central Park and Midtown sightseeing.
Hotel Alameda Highline is a small boutique with about 56–61 guestrooms in a ten-story building and five published room types.
Pick Alameda for a compact, design-led boutique stay in Chelsea.
Four Seasons has 368 individually decorated guestrooms and a broad suite inventory for more space and traditional luxury touches.
Choose Four Seasons when you want larger rooms or suites and full-service luxury appointments.
Hotel Alameda Highline emphasizes Mediterranean dining with multiple venues that move from day to night.
Alameda suits guests who want neighborhood dining and an active nightlife within the hotel.
Four Seasons provides on-site fine dining and a bar/lounge with 24-hour room service and cooked-to-order breakfast for a fee.
Four Seasons is the steadier option for formal dining and in-room service.
Hotel Alameda Highline offers a seasonal rooftop swimming pool (access usually 9 AM–7 PM).
Alameda’s rooftop pool is the draw for warm-weather stays and rooftop gatherings.
Four Seasons includes a full-service spa complex and an indoor pool as part of its wellness offerings.
Four Seasons is the better choice if you want a certified spa program and an indoor pool year-round.
Hotel Alameda Highline provides an on-site fitness center and nearby Chelsea Piers gym access for a daily fee, plus active nightlife programming.
Alameda mixes a small gym offering with active nightlife venues for evening entertainment.
Four Seasons emphasizes quieter, luxury-oriented evenings with spa, fitness and formal dining rather than club programming.
Four Seasons suits travelers who prefer refined, quieter evenings and a stronger wellness program.

Hotel Alameda Highline — steps from the High Line and close to Hudson Yards and Chelsea Market.

Four Seasons Hotel New York — large suite inventory and full-service luxury amenities.

Hotel Alameda Highline — seasonal rooftop pool and Creatures Rooftop for drinks and views.

Four Seasons Hotel New York — extensive conference center and ballroom space (about 12,120 sq ft / 1,126 m²).
Four Seasons Hotel New York is much closer to Central Park and Fifth Avenue; Hotel Alameda is in Chelsea, a longer walk or short cab ride away.
Hotel Alameda Highline has a seasonal rooftop pool (typically open in warm months). Four Seasons offers a year-round indoor pool as part of its spa/wellness facilities.
For boutique, nightlife-oriented events and rooftop parties choose Hotel Alameda; for large conferences, ballroom weddings and extensive meeting facilities choose Four Seasons.
Both welcome guests of all ages; note Hotel Alameda’s main guest check-in age requirement is 21 and Four Seasons’ minimum check-in age is 18 per their policies.
Explore how Hotel Alameda Highline stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·